Berkshire Hathaway: A Gem of a Deal in the Works?
Tuesday, July 17th, 2007As always, I appreciate when people take the time to post comments, provide feedback, or send me emails. I received an email yesterday from a reader named Connie after posting Sunday’s article The Week Ahead, which mentioned Berkshire Hathaway & Warren Buffett having an interest in Johnson & Johnson, Coca Cola, and Union Pacific - all three due to report quarterly earnings this week.
Connie writes: “Berkshire Hathaway owns Helzberg Diamonds. There is gossip that they might sale the company. Can you get some facts?”
I had not heard that Buffett/Berkshire Hathaway were looking to sell Helzberg Diamonds. Everything you read about in the financial blogs and press right now deals with the already-announced plan for Berkshire to take a stake, if not totally acquire, the homebuilder Hovnanian Enterprises (NYSE:HOV). Hovnanian has operations in 17 states, including those hit most hard by the sluggish real estate market - namely Florida and California.
With nothing published on a potential Helzberg spinoff or sale it’s entirely speculation at this point as neither the parent company Berkshire Hathaway (hereafter referred to as BRK) or subsidiary Helzberg would admit something like that unless the ink was drying on the paper.
But for the sake of arguement, let’s say it IS true that BRK wants to unload the diamond & jewelry retailer. It’s doubtful that the sale of the company would have a dramatic effect on BRK’s share price. BRK has equity interests in approximately 60 different companies. IF that equity was spread evenly among its investments that would mean that Helzberg would represent AT BEST a 1/60th proportion of BRK’s investment portfolio. We know that BRK has significant holdings in much larger companies like Coca Cola (a 8.6% stake).
But without diving into where all of BRK’s money is spread around, consider this: Warren Buffett is a long-term investor. He has owned Helzberg Diamonds since the 1990’s, which any investor would consider long-term given that it’s past the halfway point of the first decade in the 2000s. But Helzberg isn’t the only jeweler that BRK owns. Consider Borsheims, a jewelry store chain that is not so ironically based out of Omaha, NE where Buffett also calls home. BRK has owned this chain since 1989. Not to suggest that Buffett would automatically sell the business that he has owned the longest, we know that’s not the case. But I wouldn’t know how to determine which one he would be considering to sell if he thought the jewelry business was becoming over priced and wanted to cash out to bank a realized gain.
Rather than focusing on BRK and its subsidiary Helzberg, if you were to capitalize on the sale of Helzberg it would most likely be in taking a position (long or short) on the business that is acquiring Helzberg. If it’s not being acquired, namely if it’s being spun off and taken public, you have to analyze how much (if any) of the equity in the jeweler BRK is going to retain after the sale.
This might be a long shot but I could see a private equity company having an interest in Helzberg. Blackstone Group (NYSE:BX) is a good example to use because it’s publicly traded so there is more information available on it. This company recently announced it was buying Hilton Hotels (NYSE:HLT) and the deal is expected to close in October. Blackstone might be interested in Helzberg to 1) diversify and 2) as a real estate play. This is pure speculation on my part though. In fact, if a large company such as Blackstone came in and purchased Helzberg from BRK it probably wouldn’t be a sizable portion of Blackstone’s overall assets either. Blackstone might trade downward slightly on such news (so you would have a good short opportunity) as the buyer often faces some downward pressure in an acquisition while the seller often sees some increase in stock price… that’s when the seller is selling their entire company though not when they are raffling off pieces of their business.
This is probably a longer answer than most wanted, but I thought it warranted further investigation into WWWBD… What Would Warren Buffett Do? Or What WILL Warren Buffett Do?! Time will tell. As always I welcome your comments and feedback…


