How Much is YOUR Home Worth? Insurance Value vs. Market Value
Sunday, June 3rd, 2007Your home is probably one of your most expensive assets to own and maintain, and it houses not only you but many of your other assets as well. So here’s a question for you, if your home burned down or somehow was destroyed, how much would your insurance company pay?
Most people don’t know the answer off the top of their head. But this is an important thing to know because the insurance value of your home is far different than the market value of your home. You might’ve purchased your home a year ago for $150,000 and then this year your neighbor has transfered out of state and is selling his home for $160,000. Even though you just paid $150,000 for your home and your neighbor (who of course owns an identical house) has his for sale for $10,000 more than you paid, you can’t be caught up in the misconception that $150,000 or $160,000 is your home’s insurable value. Those numbers previously mentioned are the home’s market value, what a buyer would be willing to pay given the current real estate market conditions.
It’s rather easy to figure out your home’s market value if there are a lot of comparable homes in the area that are either for sale or recently sold. In fact, you can call any licensed Realtor or Appraiser and request an estimate of the value any time you want. If you want a less precise estimate, there are websites like Zillow that will help you estimate a value. When you look at these market values though you are looking at the cost of the land and everything built on it (known as the improvements). Everything from the house, the landscaping, driveway, swimming pools, fences, and so forth.
When we say the insurance value of your home we have a slightly different value in mind. If your home burns down, the insurance company does not have to buy the land (as you did when you bought the house). Instead, the insurance company is concerned with the cost to repair the damaged property - everything from site cleanup and debris removal to the actual construction cost to rebuild. In some rural areas that are not serviced by a city fire department, a volunteer fire department may even have a fee that they charge residents to come put out the fire (this is in lieu of those area residents paying taxes for the fire department’s services - or it may help subsidize the cost of those services).
In the wake of numerous hurricanes in the southern states in recent years, such as Hurricane Katrina, building materials cost have increased significantly. The cost of concrete, plywood, PVC piping, and so on are all concerns that the insurance company has to consider when pricing your homeowners insurance policy as well as when they settle claims. Therefore it is also a concern for you, as any increase in these building material costs directly corresponds with the cost to rebuild any damaged portion of your home and therefore a higher insurance value on your house. You may have purchased the house for $150,000 but if it’s a 2,000 square foot house and building materials average $100 per square foot to rebuild, your home’s insurable value is $200,000 and not the $150,000 that you paid for it.
Not to mention if you purchased an older home, it may cost more to rebuild if the home has to be brought up to current building codes.
We will revisit this issue of insurance value in future blog postings. For now, just know that the value of your home is quite different when you have to rebuild it after you suffer a loss compared to when you go to resell it. And the older your home gets, the more work it may require to bring it up to code should you ever have to rebuild it. The insurable value and the cost to bring your home up to current building codes are important things to discuss with your insurance agent - not just because the difference in value affects your insurance premiums - but also because not having enough insurance coverage in force could impair your property once a loss occurs (insurance companies often penalize you for not carrying adequate limits in the event of a loss - these are known as coinsurance penalties, we will touch on those in future blog posts!)
As always, your comments are welcome…


